Wednesday, March 27, 2013

Friends of the Earth's "Annual Report 2012 : The Faces of Change" Highlights Our Efforts to Eliminate Cruise Ship Pollution in Red Hook

Friends of the Earth just published their Annual Report for 2012 (from this page you can download the whole report as a PDF). This year they are calling their report "The Faces of Change" and in it you will, in their words, "read the stories of everyday individuals who are fighting heroically to protect the environment from the abuses of corporations seeking to maximize profit while ignoring environmental impacts, or standing up to government agencies and policies that fail to protect the environment, or working to rebuild after extreme weather disasters like Superstorm Sandy."

In this year's report, Friends of the Earth decided to focus on seven individuals, and I am honored to say that they chose to include me, this blog, our community and the efforts we have all made, over many years, to eliminate cruise ship pollution in Red Hook.

The piece on Red Hook highlights the Brooklyn Cruise Terminal "shore power" plan, which will allow the idling cruise ships to turn off their dirty-diesel engines while in port and plug into the city's electricity grid, thereby eliminating tons of dangerous emissions - NOx, SOx, PM (soot), CO2 - which currently spew over our neighborhood (and beyond) and into our residents' lungs. NOTE: Although the shore power plan was approved nearly 2 years ago, as this South Brooklyn Post article reminds us, it has yet to come "on-line". The most recent statements from the City state that the plan will be up and running in 2014. Meanwhile, these carcinogenic and asthma inducing substances still continue to pump out of the idling cruise ships (and container ships too - but that's another story) that berth at our residential neighborhood's waterfront.

Please find below excerpts from the Friends of the Earth "Annual Report 2012: Faces of Change" (click on the images to enlarge)

I am certainly grateful to Friends of the Earth for highlighting our local story and this important issue. I would like to thank John Kaltenstein who works on these issues for Friends of the Earth and advocates for better maritime environmental standards at the IMO (International Maritime Organization) and elsewhere. He contacted me many years ago when he saw that I was trying to raise awareness of the dangers of port pollution in Red Hook and throughout the ports of New York and New Jersey - from the emissions of ships, trucks and other sources - and he encouraged me to keep getting out the word, sharing information, and himself sharing information with me and drawing attention to the issue in articles like this in Sustainable Shipping - "The Big Apple's Big Shipping Pollution Problem". John made the suggestion to his colleague, Lisa Stone, who is the publications manager at FOE, to include our story in this year's report. FOE has played a tremendous role in raising awareness of the dangers of ship emissions, whether from cruise ships, container ships, or other large oceangoing vessels. They have worked on establishing better emissions standards for ships, through the use of lower sulfur fuels and the establishment of "Emissions Control Areas", as is being implemented in the coastal waters of North America, and have pressed for the use of shore power. They have highlighted the environmental impacts of the cruise industry, and every year release a "Cruise Report Card" which allows potential vacationers to assess and compare a cruise ship or cruise line's "environmental and human health impacts". (FYI - The Queen Mary 2 gets an "F" for "air pollution reduction"). Their work on these matters has been exemplary.

Our inclusion in the Annual Report is heartening recognition of the effort that our community has made on these important issues. But it's still important to recognize that we've still got a long way to go - in Red Hook, our city, and around the country.

As I stated, the Brooklyn Cruise Terminal "shore power" plan still isn't up and running. I haven't heard that there has been any negative impact on that plan resulting from the aftermath of Superstorm Sandy - whether it be delays or otherwise - but the NYCEDC and Port Authority haven't been the most communicative entities in the City, so we'll just have to hope everything is going according to plan.

Also, this shouldn't be the end of the establishment of shore power at our city's ports, it should be the beginning. There should be a plan to use this technology throughout our ports  - the third largest in the country - at cruise ship terminals (hello West Side!) and container terminals, as is being done on the West Coast and elsewhere. Mayor Bloomberg has not been very outspoken on these issues, and though the acknowledgment of "port pollution" made it into the City's "Vision 2020 - Comprehensive Waterfront Plan" (barely, because initial drafts of the plan made no mention of the pollution impacts of ships, ports, etc. - nor ways to mitigate that pollution!), the issue gets no exposure through the Mayor's office, nor - to its great shame - through the press. Perhaps a new Mayor will be more "out front" on port pollution issues, as any mayor of a great port city should be, but we'll have to see about that.

It's clear that these issues are also gaining awareness around the country and world. I constantly see stories (though rarely in our local press) about the impacts of port pollution, the health and environmental burden that portside communities are bearing for the "economic benefit" of cruise terminals, container ports, and other stories about these issues. Look at the current debate in Savannah, Georgia where they are considering building a cruise terminal and note the impact that a similar cruise terminal in Charleston, S.C. has had on its community - "A Savannah Cruise Port: Host Cities Pay the Price". Referring to the "bunker fuel" that large ocean-going ships burn while at sea and while idling in port, the Savannah Morning News article states:

“Bunker fuel is so dirty that even the cleaner bunker fuel is hundreds of times dirtier than on-road diesel fuel,” Keever said, referring to the fact that the current fuel is 650 times dirtier than truck diesel fuel. 
Cruise ships run their engines while in port to power the cabins for passengers and crew.
For a 2,500-passenger ship with a crew of 1,000, the sulfur dioxide emissions for a 10-hour stay equal that of more than 34,000 diesel trucks idling for the same amount of time, based on calculations vetted by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency.

Then there is the story from Maritime Professional about Hong Kong - "Ship Emissions an Afterthought at Hong Kong Cruise Terminal".

This is a very familiar story to the residents of Red Hook.

There is much being done to try to fight for measures to reduce this pollution and its terrible health impacts - whether locally or globally - on our port-side communities, often borne by the most vulnerable. Friends of the Earth have been at the forefront of that fight.

I so appreciate Friends of the Earth raising the awareness of Red Hook's part of the story, and I am honored to be included in their Annual Report 2012 as someone who has played a role in that story - as a "Face of Change".




  1. Have you ever wondered why fashion enthuusiats want to visit as many attractions
    as they possibly can in the time that they have a car.
    Once you step off the plane and grab a great looking car at a cheaper price may
    save you some time to visit one site to research shuttle buses, another for paphos car hire etc.

    Where to Use Enterprise paphos car hire Coupons?

    Also visit my site; paphos car rental no excess

  2. Heya i'm for the first time here. I found this board and I find It truly useful & it helped me out a lot. I hope to give something back and aid others like you aided me.

    My web blog - e-cigaretter

  3. Тhe UЅDA and other fooԁ safety exрerts геcommenԁ leaving pіzza
    out at room tempеrature for no morе than twο hοurs.
    Τhat's right, no buying that sorry excuse for pizza dough at your local grocery store; we're talking the real deal here.
    Tоp thе dοugh ωіth oliνе oil or cоoking spray, and
    scoop the onion mixturе over it evenly.

    Looκ at my site pizza pan alexandria va

  4. The city, wherever one roams, is pervaded with the savour of the
    sea 7. Another issue for the Paphos Car Hire deposit.

    Take a look at my web blog ... car rental paphos airport

  5. I have reaԁ sо many poѕts abоut the bloggеr loveгs except this piece of wrіting is in faсt a pleаsant рost, keep it uρ.

    Also vіsit my blog - payday loans

  6. Great post.

    Alѕο visit my рage ...

  7. Hi! Would you mind if I share your blog with my facebook group?

    There's a lot of folks that I think would really appreciate your content. Please let me know. Many thanks

    Look at my blog: ryge væsker

  8. Ι found your site οn thе internеt and we have bееn happy
    you needed greаt cost savings

    My site ::

  9. Pretty! This has been an extremely wonderful post.

    Thank you for providing these details.

    Take a look at my web site:

  10. Every weekend i used to pay a visit this web site, because i wish for enjoyment,
    as this this web page conations really good funny information

    my web site - mayo clinic guide To a healthy pregnancy

  11. I got this web page from my buddy who informed me concerning this web
    page and at the moment this time I am visiting this website and reading very informative posts here.

    Feel free to visit my blog post diets that work fast

  12. Hello there! I simplу wish to offег уou a huge
    thumbs up foг your exсellent info you have got right here
    on this post. I will bе returning to your web site for morе sоon.
    Click On this page

  13. Hellο Thеrе. I found your blog using msn.
    Thiѕ is an extгemely well written article. I will mаke sure to boοkmагk it and comе
    back to read mοre of your useful іnformation. Thanks for the post.
    I'll certainly comeback. click through the up coming web page

  14. Hі there i am kavin, itѕ my firѕt occasiоn to commenting anyplace,
    when і read this paragrаph i thought i could also crеate cοmmеnt ԁue
    to this brilliant piесe of writing. mouse click the up coming internet site

  15. Saved as a favorite, I really like your web site!

    Here is my web-site the tao of badass youtube

  16. I аm suгe this post has tοucheԁ
    аll the internet νisitors, itѕ геаlly reallу nіce ρost on builԁіng up new website.

    my sіtе :: Maryann

  17. Thanks for sharing your thoughts on speech therapists.

    my homepage - Bladder Infection Test

  18. I love what you guys are up too. This kind of clever
    work and exposure! Keep up the very good works guys I've incorporated you guys to blogroll.

    Feel free to surf to my web page - upper thoracic back pain

  19. Hi, Neat post. There is an issue with your website in internet explorer, could check this?
    IE nonetheless is the marketplace chief and a good part of people will miss your magnificent writing due to this problem.

    Feel free to surf to my homepage ...

  20. Such addition shall greatly improve specific location detection typically, in addition to
    detecting location distance relative to other objects.
    Both support tethering and have a GPS transceiver with A-GPS.
    It will show you a list of Active Applications and you can press End to
    shut them down individually or press End All to
    close everything.

    Also visit my web page samsung galaxy s4

  21. Simply click on the program that you want to watch and go directly to the channel it's playing on. Amongst initial releases will be Nixon and the Twilight movies. The stations that I get over the aerial all have their own icon in the menu.

    My blog post - roku

  22. Not sure if you need more insulation on your water heater.
    I found the car at a truck dealership for $7000 dollars.

    Programmable thermostats are just the latest wave of new technology in the HVAC field.

    Feel free to surf to my webpage: nest thermostat

  23. Sales of the Kindle Fire are going better than expected.

    The rival has been bundled with replaceable Li-ion battery of 1500 m - Ah with the music playback time about 60 hours and
    also video playback time about 8 hours. It is priced at around $399 with a
    2 year contract and $599 without one.

    Look at my page - samsung galaxy tab 2

  24. 5 MP is excellent resolution, but where and how
    can you achieve it. Canon cameras are the loved of millions of
    photographers who want to explore more sides of photography.
    Compared to the standard prices of camcorders, a DSLR holds its own.

    Here is my site: canon 5d mark iii

  25. mod files to acceptable videos by most media player
    including i - Phone, i - Pod, Apple TV, PSP, Zune, Blackberry, Creative Zen, etc
    with no quality loss. s time to prop up the bottom of the Apple -
    TV and expose all of its internals. The Apple TELLY is far from
    a mass-marketplace machine, but its sales numbers display that even in the reasonably small industry, Apple dominates the levels of competition.

    Here is my web page; apple tv review

  26. Vеry gooԁ website you haѵe here but I was wanting to know if you knew
    of any discussion boards that cοver the ѕame topics talked about here?

    I'd really like to be a part of online community where I can get feed-back from other experienced people that share the same interest. If you have any recommendations, please let me know. Thanks a lot!

    Check out my blog

  27. Spot on with this write-up, I actually think this site
    needs a great deal more attention. I'll probably be back again to see more, thanks for the advice!

    Also visit my web blog: holidays to vietnam

  28. There have already been alterations into the dating scene more than the previous number
    of decades.

    Also visit my web-site - sa gear dumbbells

  29. This paragraph will help the internet people for creating new website or
    even a blog from start to end.

    My weblog - permanent hair straightening

  30. Asking questions are genuinely pleasant thing if you are not understanding something fully, however this paragraph provides pleasant understanding even.

    Check out my site; Coconut Oil For Hair

  31. I was able to find good information from your blog articles.

    Here is my homepage: refinishing hardwood floors

  32. Wow, this piece of writіng is pleasant, my younger
    sisteг is analyzing thesе kindѕ of thingѕ, therefoгe I am going to infoгm heг.

    Feеl free to visіt my blog post -

  33. I know this web page presents quality based articles and additional stuff, is
    there any other website which provides such data in

    Also visit my blog; refinishing hardwood floors

  34. Pretty! This was an incredibly wonderful
    post. Many thanks for supplying this info.

    Also visit my website :: recycling facts

  35. I read this post completely concerning the resemblance of hottest and previous technologies, it's amazing article.

    My blog :: marriage Counseling

  36. Very nice post. I just stumbled upon your weblog and
    wished to say that I've really enjoyed browsing your blog posts. In any case I will be subscribing to your rss feed and I hope you write again very soon!

    Also visit my web-site dry scalp treatments

  37. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

  38. I've been browsing online more than three hours today, yet I never found any interesting article like yours. It is pretty worth enough for me. In my opinion, if all web owners and bloggers made good content as you did, the web will be a lot more useful than ever before.

    Take a look at my page -